Part II
Foreign Counts
Offences against other peoples, usually in defence of somebody's oil, fruit or mining concession. Listed with the host country first, out of courtesy.
No peace treaty
1950–1953
The Bombing of North Korea
Count 7: Flattening a country from the air
During the Korean War, the U.S.-led air campaign against the North dropped large quantities of high explosives and napalm on cities, towns and villages, and destroyed most of the urban areas of the North, Pyongyang included. In 1953 U.S. aircraft bombed irrigation dams, flooding farmland and rice crops.
The fighting stopped with the 1953 armistice. No peace treaty has ever been signed.
Sentence: none. Reward offered by the defendant, 70 years on, for information about the victims' hackers: up to $10 million.
Sources: Bombing of North Korea · Korean Armistice Agreement
Regret noted
July 1950
No Gun Ri
Count 8: Shooting refugees under a railroad bridge
In late July 1950, U.S. troops near the village of No Gun Ri in South Korea opened fire on a column of South Korean refugees sheltering under a railroad bridge. The death toll is disputed. Survivors put it in the hundreds.
The killings were buried for almost fifty years until an Associated Press investigation in 1999, which won a Pulitzer Prize. The Army's own review in 2001 called it a tragedy, found no orders to fire, and President Clinton expressed regret. He did not apologize.
Sentence: one statement of regret, issued to an ally.
Source: No Gun Ri massacre
Admitted 2013
August 1953
Iran: Operation Ajax
Count 9: Unlicensed regime change (first offence on file)
After Iran's elected prime minister, Mohammad Mosaddegh, nationalized the British-owned Anglo-Iranian Oil Company, the CIA and Britain's MI6 organized the coup that removed him and restored the Shah to power. The Shah ruled for another quarter century with the help of the SAVAK secret police, until the 1979 revolution.
The CIA formally acknowledged its role in documents declassified in 2013, sixty years after the fact.
Sentence: none. Blowback ongoing.
Source: 1953 Iranian coup d'état
June 1954
Guatemala: Operation PBSuccess
Count 10: Regime change on behalf of a fruit company
President Jacobo Árbenz, elected in 1950, carried out a land reform that expropriated unused land, including large holdings of the U.S.-owned United Fruit Company. The CIA organized, armed and funded the force that overthrew him in 1954. A string of military governments followed, and then a civil war that lasted until 1996.
In 1999 President Clinton said in Guatemala that U.S. support for the security forces responsible for the repression had been wrong.
Sentence: none. The bananas were delivered on time.
Source: 1954 Guatemalan coup d'état
1960–1961
Congo: Patrice Lumumba
Count 11: Conspiracy to assassinate a head of government
Patrice Lumumba became the first prime minister of the independent Congo in 1960. The CIA plotted to kill him, and its chief chemist, Sidney Gottlieb of MKUltra fame, delivered poison to the Congo for the purpose. That plot was never carried out. Lumumba was deposed, handed to his Katangan enemies, and executed in January 1961 with Belgian involvement.
The plot was documented by the Church Committee in 1975. The United States then backed Mobutu Sese Seko for three decades.
Verdict: guilty of conspiracy. Belgium got there first.
Sources: Patrice Lumumba · Church Committee
Did not happen
August 1964
The Gulf of Tonkin Incident
Count 12: Filing a false report to start a war
On August 2, 1964, the destroyer USS Maddox exchanged fire with North Vietnamese torpedo boats. A second attack was reported on August 4. It did not happen. On the strength of both reports, Congress passed the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution, which the Johnson administration used to escalate the war in Vietnam.
An NSA historical study declassified in 2005 concluded that no attack took place on August 4.
Sentence: none. The tip was bad and paid out anyway.
Source: Gulf of Tonkin incident
Cables released 2017
1965–1966
Indonesia
Count 13: Accessory to mass killing
After a failed coup attempt in 1965, the Indonesian army and allied militias killed hundreds of thousands of people accused of being communists, including ethnic Chinese Indonesians. Many of the dead were peasants, workers and union members tied to the communist party's mass organizations. General Suharto took power and ruled for over three decades.
U.S. officials supported the army throughout, and U.S. diplomats reportedly provided the army with lists of names of communist party members. Embassy cables declassified in 2017 showed how closely Washington followed the killings.
Sentence: none. A list of names is a tip, after all.
Source: Indonesian mass killings of 1965–66
March 16, 1968
My Lai
Count 14: Massacre of a village, followed by a cover-up
A U.S. Army company killed hundreds of unarmed villagers in My Lai, South Vietnam, most of them women, children and old men. The Army suppressed the story until a soldier's letters and Seymour Hersh's reporting exposed it in 1969.
One soldier, Lt. William Calley, was convicted. He was sentenced to life, and after President Nixon intervened he served about three and a half years, mostly under house arrest.
Sentence: one conviction for one village. Credit for time served at home.
Source: My Lai massacre
1970–1973
Chile: Salvador Allende
Count 15: Destabilizing a democracy for the crime of electing a socialist
When Salvador Allende won the 1970 election, President Nixon ordered the CIA to prevent him from taking office, and then to put economic pressure on Chile once he had. The CIA funded opposition parties and press, and was in contact with officers plotting a coup. On September 11, 1973, the military under Augusto Pinochet overthrew Allende, who died in the presidential palace. The United States quickly backed the junta, which killed and disappeared thousands of people.
Sentence: none. Henry Kissinger received the Nobel Peace Prize the same year, for Vietnam.
Sources: United States intervention in Chile · 1973 Chilean coup d'état
1975–1980s
Operation Condor
Count 16: Aiding and abetting a multinational kidnapping network
The military dictatorships of Chile, Argentina, Uruguay, Paraguay, Bolivia and Brazil pooled their intelligence services to hunt down, torture and kill leftists, unionists and dissidents across each other's borders. The United States knew about the network and supported the regimes involved.
In September 1976 Condor reached Washington, D.C., when a car bomb planted by agents of Chile's secret police killed former Chilean minister Orlando Letelier and his American colleague Ronni Moffitt.
Sentence: none. Terrorism in the capital, by a client state, did not trigger a reward.
Sources: Operation Condor · Orlando Letelier
Judgment ignored
1981–1986
Nicaragua and the Contras
Count 17: Unlawful use of force (as found by an actual court)
After the Sandinista revolution, the United States armed and funded the Contra rebels and the CIA mined Nicaragua's harbors. In 1986 the International Court of Justice ruled that the United States had violated international law and owed Nicaragua reparations. The U.S. rejected the court's jurisdiction, never paid, and vetoed Security Council resolutions calling for compliance.
When Congress cut off Contra funding, officials sold arms to Iran and diverted the proceeds to the Contras. In 1992 President George H. W. Bush pardoned six people involved in the Iran-Contra affair.
Sentence: imposed by the World Court. Declined by the defendant.
Sources: Nicaragua v. United States · Iran–Contra affair
Ex gratia
July 3, 1988
Iran Air Flight 655
Count 18: Shooting down a civilian airliner
The cruiser USS Vincennes shot down an Iran Air Airbus over the Persian Gulf, in Iranian territorial waters, killing all 290 people on board. The ship's commanding officer later received the Legion of Merit for his tour of duty.
In 1996 the United States agreed to pay $61.8 million to the victims' families, without admitting legal liability, and it has never formally apologized.
Sentence: a medal for the captain.
Source: Iran Air Flight 655
No WMD found
2003
Iraq
Count 19: Invading a country on the strength of a bad tip
The United States invaded Iraq in March 2003 on the stated grounds that Saddam Hussein's government held weapons of mass destruction, a case Secretary of State Colin Powell presented to the UN Security Council that February. Part of it rested on a single informant code-named "Curveball". The Iraq Survey Group's final report in 2004 found no stockpiles.
Sentence: none. The informant was wrong, and the war went ahead anyway. The Bureau notes that bad tips are not a disqualifier.
Sources: Iraq and weapons of mass destruction · Curveball (informant)
2003–2004
Abu Ghraib
Count 20: Torture and abuse of prisoners, with photographs
U.S. soldiers at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq abused, humiliated and tortured detainees, and photographed it. The photos became public in April 2004. Several low-ranking soldiers were court-martialed and convicted. No senior official who approved the interrogation policies behind it was ever prosecuted.
Sentence: served by the enlisted ranks.
Source: Abu Ghraib torture and prisoner abuse
Tapes destroyed
2002–2009
Guantánamo, CIA Torture and Extraordinary Rendition
Count 21: Kidnapping, secret prisons and "enhanced" interrogation
The CIA held prisoners in secret "black sites" abroad, transferred others to foreign governments known for torture, and waterboarded detainees. Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was waterboarded 183 times. In 2005 the CIA destroyed videotapes of its interrogations. The Senate Intelligence Committee's 2014 report concluded that the program was more brutal than the CIA had represented and did not produce the intelligence claimed for it.
Canadian engineer Maher Arar was detained at JFK airport in 2002 and sent to Syria, where he was tortured. Canada cleared him, apologized and compensated him. The United States has done neither. The Guantánamo Bay prison opened in January 2002; President Obama ordered it closed in 2009. It is still open.
Sentence: none for the torturers. The only CIA officer to go to prison in connection with the program, John Kiriakou, went for a leak.
Sources: Senate report on CIA torture · Maher Arar · Guantanamo Bay detention camp
Tragic mistake
2002–present
Drone Strikes
Count 22: Extrajudicial killing by remote control
In 2011 a U.S. drone strike in Yemen killed Anwar al-Awlaki, a U.S. citizen, without trial. About two weeks later, another strike killed his 16-year-old son, Abdulrahman, also a U.S. citizen.
On August 29, 2021, during the withdrawal from Afghanistan, a U.S. drone strike in Kabul killed ten civilians, among them an aid worker and seven children. Military leaders first defended the strike, then the Pentagon admitted it was a tragic mistake. Nobody was disciplined.
Sentence: none. Due process was performed by a Hellfire missile.
Sources: August 2021 Kabul drone strike · Abdulrahman al-Awlaki