Part 1
How the U.S. Treats Hackers
Rewards for Justice offers up to $10 million for tips on hackers who target U.S. critical infrastructure. Here is what the same government has done to hackers, researchers and cryptographers when no reward was involved. All entries are from the public record.
RAID FOUND UNLAWFUL
1990
Steve Jackson Games and Operation Sundevil
Charged with: Publishing a role-playing game supplement
In March 1990 the Secret Service raided Steve Jackson Games in Austin and seized computers, including one running the company's bulletin board and a draft of the GURPS Cyberpunk sourcebook. The raid was part of the wider Operation Sundevil crackdown. No charges were ever filed against the company.
The company sued and won in 1993: the court found the Secret Service had violated the Privacy Protection Act and the Electronic Communications Privacy Act. The Electronic Frontier Foundation, founded in 1990, took on the case as an early cause.
Reviewer comment: the sourcebook was, in fact, about cyberpunk.
Sources: Wikipedia: the lawsuit · Wikipedia: Operation Sundevil
1995-1999
Kevin Mitnick
Charged with: Being very good at the telephone
Mitnick was arrested in 1995 and spent roughly five years in custody before pleading guilty in 1999, much of that time awaiting trial. By his own account, he was held in solitary confinement for months, and prosecutors persuaded a judge he was dangerous because, as Mitnick tells it, officials claimed he could start a nuclear war by whistling into a phone. We pass that along as his account.
Threat model: one man, one whistle.
Sources: Wikipedia: Kevin Mitnick
NO CHARGES FILED
1993-1996
Phil Zimmermann and PGP
Charged with: Exporting math
After PGP spread worldwide, Zimmermann was investigated by a U.S. Customs-led grand jury inquiry over possible violations of arms export rules, which classed strong cryptography as a munition. He had published the source code as a book. The investigation was closed in January 1996 with no charges.
Status of the book: still a book.
Sources: Wikipedia: Phil Zimmermann · Wikipedia: Pretty Good Privacy
1995-2000s
Bernstein v. United States
Charged with: Arms trafficking by way of a mathematics paper
Cryptographer Daniel Bernstein, then a graduate student, sued over export rules that required a license to publish his encryption algorithm's source code. In 1999 the Ninth Circuit held that source code is protected speech under the First Amendment. The government later rewrote the export rules.
Our own code is also speech. Mostly ours is mean speech.
Sources: Wikipedia: Bernstein v. United States
CASE DISMISSED
2001
Dmitry Sklyarov
Charged with: Giving a talk, then leaving the hotel
Sklyarov, a Russian programmer, was arrested in Las Vegas in July 2001 after speaking at DEF CON about weaknesses in Adobe's eBook software. He was charged under the DMCA's anti-circumvention provisions. The charges against him were dropped, and his employer Elcomsoft was acquitted at trial in 2002.
Welcome to America. Please enjoy your stay.
Sources: Wikipedia: Dmitry Sklyarov
TALK GAGGED
2008
The MIT students and the subway
Charged with: Scheduling a conference talk
Three MIT students planned a DEF CON talk on weaknesses in Boston's MBTA fare system. The transit agency sued, and a federal judge issued a temporary restraining order barring the talk. The order was later lifted. The slides had already been handed out.
The vulnerability: still a vulnerability.
Sources: Wikipedia: MBTA v. Anderson
CASE DISMISSED (POSTHUMOUSLY)
2011-2013
Aaron Swartz
Charged with: Downloading too many academic papers
Swartz was indicted in 2011 for downloading a large number of articles from JSTOR over the MIT network, and later faced 13 felony counts under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. He died in January 2013, and the case was dropped after his death. He was 26.
We offer no joke here. His charges were also no joke.
Sources: Wikipedia: Aaron Swartz
TIME SERVED
2017-2019
Marcus Hutchins
Charged with: Stopping WannaCry, then flying home
In May 2017 Hutchins found and triggered the kill switch that halted WannaCry's spread. In August, as he was leaving Las Vegas after DEF CON, he was arrested and charged over earlier work related to the Kronos banking malware. He pleaded guilty to two counts in 2019 and was sentenced to time served.
Reward for stopping the worm: lodging at Las Vegas's finest.
Sources: Wikipedia: Marcus Hutchins
EXTRADITION DENIED
2002-2018
Gary McKinnon and Lauri Love
Charged with: Hacking U.S. systems, from Britain
McKinnon, accused of breaking into U.S. military and NASA systems, fought extradition for a decade until Home Secretary Theresa May blocked it in 2012 on human rights grounds, citing his health. Lauri Love, accused of intrusions into U.S. government networks, won his appeal against extradition in the UK High Court in 2018.
The U.S. has not been able to extradite our fugitives either. We feel seen.
Sources: Wikipedia: Gary McKinnon · Wikipedia: Lauri Love
SENTENCE COMMUTED
2010-2017
Chelsea Manning
Charged with: Giving journalists what taxpayers paid for
Manning, an Army intelligence analyst, gave classified material to WikiLeaks. She was convicted in 2013 and sentenced to 35 years. President Obama commuted the sentence in January 2017, and she was released that May.
Sources: Wikipedia: Chelsea Manning
PARDONED: NO
2013-present
Edward Snowden
Charged with: Telling Americans what their government was doing
Snowden disclosed NSA surveillance programs in 2013. The U.S. charged him under the Espionage Act, and he has lived in Russia since. He has not been pardoned.
Section 2 of this page is, in large part, his fault.
Sources: Wikipedia: Edward Snowden